Venchi, premium Italian chocolate and gelato, founded 1878. Globally 200+ owned stores across 70 countries and 6,000+ wholesale doors. In the US, 23 owned stores concentrated in NYC and the Northeast, with clusters in Florida and California and openings planned for Texas and both coasts in 2027.
All product is made at one factory in Castelletto Stura, Italy and reaches the US through the group's central warehouse in Lodi. There is an incumbent US 3PL; Venchi rents space inside that warehouse and staffs its own gift box production there.
They issued a formal RFQ on Jul 23. We met them in person on Aug 7 and received SKU, order and stock data the same day, folded into the numbers below.
This is not a chocolate-only operation, and that is the part most 3PLs get wrong when they first look at it. Chocolate is about three-quarters of shipped case volume. The rest is gelato production inputs, packaging and consumables for the store estate, and staff uniforms, all moving through the same building on the same order lines.
Split is now sourced, not verbal: Venchi's own 2025 shipment data (147,050 cases across 48,227 order lines) puts chocolate at 74% of case volume and everything else at 26%. That's more cold-weighted than the client's own earlier verbal estimate of 50–60% — worth re-running any space/rate assumption built on the old split.
| Family | What is in it | Storage | Handling note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate | Bars, pralines, gift boxes, hampers, seasonal ranges | Temperature-controlled | Drives the whole cold-chain requirement and the heat-season shipping rules. Bars run about 200 cases to a pallet. |
| Gelato inputs | Gelato bases and gelato ingredients for the store estate | Ask: ambient, chilled or frozen | Feeds stores rather than consumers. Whether any of it needs chilled or frozen space is an open question and would make it a third zone. |
| Packaging & consumables | Spoons, cups, napkins, empty gift boxes | Dry / ambient | Empty gift boxes are also the raw input to the co-packing line, so this stock is consumed in-house as well as shipped. |
| Uniforms & store supplies | Staff uniforms and non-food store items | Dry / ambient | Counted oddly: a single shirt is booked as one case. This is the main reason the case unit needs defining before anything is priced per case. |
Three outbound shapes, all picked by the case. There is no full-pallet picking anywhere in the operation.
Amazon Vendor sits in the D2C channel table but behaves like none of these: 100 orders a year at 333 units each, which is a purchase-order and pallet flow with routing guides attached.
One partner across four workstreams. Venchi wants them under one roof rather than split.
| Workstream | Detail |
|---|---|
| Inbound & storage | Container receiving, put-away, temperature-controlled storage for chocolate, dry/ambient space for packaging, gift box components and non-sensitive goods. |
| B2B outbound | Replenishment to Venchi's own retail stores, palletized. Wholesale to department stores and independent retail, palletized above roughly 10–15 cartons and parcel below. |
| D2C e-commerce | Venchi.com, Amazon Vendor and FBM, Goldbelly, DoorDash, Faire, department store dropship. Includes parcel management, carrier integration, double-scan verification, returns, customer-care interface. |
| Co-packing | Gift box assembly and kitting on an ongoing production basis, plus seasonal kitting, relabeling, repacking, promotional bundles. Venchi intends to move this to the 3PL and later centralise store-level production into the warehouse. |
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Pallet locations today | ~1,000, mixed / multi-SKU |
| Chocolate alone | ~500 pallets, full |
Given verbally, not from the SKU export, so treat as a size check rather than a precise footprint.
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Pallets in | 2,000–2,100 |
| Containers in | 80–90 |
| Cases received | 200,000, averaging 100 per pallet |
| Mixed pallets | 5 SKUs per pallet on average, ranging from 1 to 20 |
| Max pallet height | 6.8 ft from ocean containers, 5.08 ft from air |
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Orders shipped | 1,275 in 2025 (553 store, 477 wholesale, the balance Eataly/Faire/e-tailers), including replenishment into the e-commerce area |
| Cases shipped | 147,050 in 2025, Sep–Dec alone accounting for 35% of the year, confirming the Q4 peak |
| Average SKUs per order | 70 for store replenishment orders (median 69, up to 222 on a single order), 9 for wholesale |
| Pallet type | American Grade B |
| Channel | Orders | Units | Units / order |
|---|---|---|---|
| Venchi.com | 25,873 | 111,529 | 4.3 |
| Amazon, excl. Vendor | 13,578 | 27,155 | 2.0 |
| Amazon Vendor | 100 | 33,333 | 333.3 |
| Etailers & dept. store dropship | 1,096 | 12,181 | 11.1 |
| Faire | 2,475 | 142,983 | 57.8 |
Venchi.com and Amazon are each-pick parcel work. Faire and Amazon Vendor are case and pallet flows sitting in the same table. We have asked Venchi to split this by fulfillment shape before anyone prices it.
On the case unit: Venchi's "case" is a system unit rather than a physical carton, and we now have the real conversion from their 2025 shipment data: chocolate averages 12 units per case, gelato inputs 10, café/store consumables (cups, napkins, prep supplies) 400, and uniforms/equipment/furniture sit at 1:1, a shirt is still booked as one case. Bars separately run about 200 cases to a pallet.
The RFQ sets +30% in 2027, then +25% in each of 2028 and 2029. Separately it states an intent to double US retail presence, triple online sales and double wholesale by 2029. Those two framings do not reconcile and we have it flagged with the client.
| Requirement | Detail |
|---|---|
| Northeast location | New York centre of gravity, driven by European imports and the store base. Remote low-cost geographies ruled out by the client directly. |
| Temperature control | 32°F to 65°F for food inventory, variation not exceeding 8°F inside the controlled area, relative humidity at or below 65%. Continuous records and alarms, with a defined escalation process. |
| Dual space | Controlled storage for food plus dry/ambient for packaging, gift boxes and copack activity. Roughly half the inventory is chocolate; the balance is gelato bases, gelato ingredients and dry goods. |
| Food safety | HACCP, pest control, hygiene standards and client audit access mandatory. FSSC 22000 or ISO 22000 strongly preferred. Segregation from fish, cheese, chemicals and odorous goods. |
| Multi-SKU locations | Venchi rarely holds a full pallet of a single batch. The incumbent stores multiple SKUs and multiple batches per location and bills per case. One SKU per location has been named as a disqualifier. |
| Case picking | No full-pallet picking anywhere. Store orders average 40 SKUs and can reach 200–300 unique SKUs on a single order. |
| FEFO and traceability | FEFO mandatory, lot, batch and expiry tracking in the WMS, recall hold and release, two physical counts a year, daily cycle counts on request down to a single SKU. |
| D2C service levels | Cutoff 10:00 AM ET for same-day shipping, orders before cutoff shipped within 24 hours. Standard shipping Monday to Friday, no weekends and no US federal holidays. Peak periods allow +1 business day. |
| Heat-season handling | A fixed May–September Monday-to-Wednesday shipping window in the written RFQ, with orders after Wednesday noon ET held to Monday. The client describes something more active in practice: watching weather by destination and choosing shipping method accordingly, Florida, Texas and California especially. |
| KPIs | B2B: damage at or below 0.10%, picking accuracy at or above 99.9%, inventory accuracy at or above 99.8%, inbound and order-processing lead times under 24 hours. D2C: fulfillment accuracy at or above 99.5%, on-time at or above 99.0%, temperature compliance 100%. Respondents are asked to state whether they accept a service-credit or bonus-malus mechanism tied to these. |
| Integration | Microsoft D365 F&O is the system of record, with Workato and Azure Service Bus notifications, plus Shopify, Amazon, Faire and UPS/FedEx/USPS. Respondents also state whether they can receive Venchi master data or must manage it themselves, and provide a BCP and disaster recovery approach. |
| Insurance | Warehouse legal liability or bailee coverage at a $5M minimum per occurrence. Perishable goods coverage must respond to loss from temperature or humidity excursion, power or equipment failure, and handling error. Cargo at $1M minimum per shipment where the partner controls transport, umbrella $5M preferred, cyber and technology E&O $1M to $2M preferred. Deductibles and sublimits must be disclosed, along with any exclusion covering temperature excursion. |
| Commercial | Three-year term. Venchi holds a right to terminate at the end of Year 1 for sustained KPI failure. |
| Headroom over polish | Said directly by the client: B2B is their certain, current business today. D2C is an expectation, not a certainty. They'd rather have a partner who can absorb more volume than today's requirements, including a future large-format account, than one optimized for D2C sophistication they may not need. Lead with B2B execution and scale headroom. |
| # | Question |
|---|---|
| 1 | When does the New Jersey site go live, what is the temperature and dry footprint there, and could it carry this account by a target transition of April 2027? If it opens later than that, could Wallace or Bedford bridge it? |
| 2 | Can you hold 32–65°F with variation inside 8°F and humidity at or below 65%, and produce continuous records against it? |
| 3 | Do you store multiple SKUs and multiple batches per location, and can you price storage per case rather than per pallet position? |
| 4 | How much palletized B2B retail replenishment do you run today, given orders that can carry 200–300 unique SKUs? This is roughly half the case volume. |
| 5 | What is your appetite for ongoing gift box production as a standing line rather than occasional kitting, including a path to absorb store-level production later? |
| 6 | Does the insurance profile work, particularly $5M bailee and perishable coverage that responds to temperature excursion? |
This is roughly what the brand likes a proposal to cover. None of it is a hurdle, it is just what they are used to having in front of them when they compare partners.
Data review and partner shortlisting run through August. From there the sequence is roughly:
The middle of that is deliberately loose and will move with how quickly the data comes together. The one fixed point is transition complete by April 2027.